Table of Contents
The Division of the Carolingian Empire
The division of the Carolingian Empire in the ninth century marked a decisive turning point in the political landscape of medieval Europe. What had once been a vast, unified realm under Charlemagne fragmented into separate kingdoms that followed distinct historical paths. This process began formally with the Treaty of Verdun in 843, which ended the civil wars among Charlemagne’s grandsons and distributed the empire into three major realms. These divisions reflected both the competing claims of its rulers and the underlying regional identities that had long existed within the Carolingian world. In the centuries that followed, these realms evolved into the political units that would form the basis of medieval France, Germany, and parts of Italy and the Low Countries.
The Treaty of Verdun and the Threefold Division
The Treaty of Verdun divided the empire among the three surviving sons of Louis the Pious, Charlemagne’s son and successor. Lothair I, the eldest, received the “Middle Kingdom,” stretching from the North Sea through the Low Countries, over the Rhine Valley, Burgundy, and northern Italy, with the imperial title attached. Louis the German gained the eastern territories, which became known as East Francia, centered on the lands of the Bavarians, Saxons, Alemanni, and Thuringians. Charles the Bald inherited West Francia, the western regions corresponding roughly to modern France.
Although the treaty is often seen as the moment when modern European states began to emerge, the division was initially more dynastic than national. Nevertheless, linguistic, cultural, and political differences among the regions grew more pronounced, shaping their subsequent development.
East Francia: The Foundations of the German Kingdom
East Francia evolved into the most stable and coherent of the post-Verdun kingdoms. Under Louis the German and his successors, regional duchies such as Saxony, Bavaria, Swabia, and Franconia gained increasing autonomy but also formed the core from which the German kingdom later emerged. The Carolingian lineage continued in East Francia until the late ninth century, after which local dynasties took prominence.
In 919, the election of Henry the Fowler, a Saxon noble, marked a significant step toward a new form of monarchy. His son, Otto the Great, strengthened royal authority, conquered Italy, and revived the imperial title in 962. From East Francia thus emerged the Holy Roman Empire, a political entity that claimed to continue the legacy of Charlemagne but developed along distinct, German-dominated lines.
West Francia: The Road Toward Medieval France
West Francia faced greater fragmentation than its eastern counterpart. Charles the Bald struggled to maintain control over powerful nobles who increasingly acted as independent rulers in their own regions. Viking raids further destabilized the kingdom, forcing Charles to grant lands and privileges to local lords in exchange for military protection.
Over time, the authority of the Carolingian kings eroded, and the monarchy became largely symbolic. The real power lay with regional aristocrats such as the Robertians, who eventually replaced the Carolingians on the throne. In 987, Hugh Capet, duke of the Île-de-France, was elected king, founding the Capetian dynasty. Although small in territory, the Capetian monarchy slowly strengthened its position, laying the foundations for the later Kingdom of France.
West Francia thus transitioned from a Carolingian realm into a feudal patchwork of principalities, each governed by powerful local lords. The French kingdom that emerged from this landscape was shaped by the interplay of dynastic continuity, territorial consolidation, and shifting aristocratic loyalties.
The Middle Kingdom: Lotharingia and Its Fragmented Legacy
The middle realm given to Lothair I was geographically vast but lacked internal cohesion. Stretching from the North Sea to Italy, it consisted of diverse peoples, languages, and traditions. After Lothair’s death in 855, the realm was further subdivided among his sons, creating the regions of Lotharingia, Provence, and the Kingdom of Italy.
Lotharingia, the northern portion, became a contested zone between East and West Francia. Lying between two rising powers, it often shifted hands and ultimately became fragmented into duchies and counties, influencing the later development of territories such as Lorraine, the Low Countries, and parts of western Germany. Italy, meanwhile, developed its own trajectory marked by rivalry between local nobles, foreign interventions, and competing claims to the imperial title.
The Middle Kingdom did not survive as a unified political entity, but its territories played a crucial role in shaping the cultural and political geography of Western Europe.
Long-Term Consequences of the Fragmentation
The breakup of the Carolingian Empire set in motion the development of political structures that would define the European Middle Ages. Local power grew, giving rise to the feudal order and to a network of duchies, counties, bishoprics, and principalities. The idea of a universal empire remained important, especially in East Francia and later the Holy Roman Empire, but it never again achieved the unity of Charlemagne’s reign.
Meanwhile, West Francia moved toward the creation of a more centralized monarchy, though this process was slow and uneven. The Middle Kingdom’s legacy lived on in regions marked by fluid political boundaries and cultural diversity.
Even though the Carolingian Empire dissolved, its influence persisted. The division established by the Treaty of Verdun laid the groundwork for the political map of medieval Europe, and its legacy is visible in the modern distinctions between France, Germany, Italy, and the Benelux countries.
Conclusion: The End of Imperial Unity and the Birth of Medieval Europe
The fragmentation of the Carolingian Empire did not signify collapse but transformation. The three Frankish realms that emerged after the division developed their own identities, institutions, and political cultures. They inherited the memory of Charlemagne’s empire and shaped it into new forms that reflected regional realities.
From this process arose the medieval kingdoms and empires that would dominate European history for centuries. The dissolution of the Carolingian unity thus marks the beginning of Europe as a mosaic of interconnected but distinct polities, a political landscape that would continue to evolve throughout the Middle Ages.